 |
| Photo by Choo Meng Foo |
Sidewalk Cantata: Notes from the City’s Edge
By Choo Meng Foo with Hamamoto Satoshi
“To dwell is to leave traces.”
— Walter Benjamin
“The Dao is everywhere. It is in the ant and the blade of grass.”
— Zhuangzi
“Good city streets are like great public rooms—places where people feel at home among strangers.”
— Jan Gehl
There are photographs that proclaim, and there are photographs that whisper.
This image—taken on a busy street in Kuala Lumpur’s Bukit Bintang—does not announce itself. It waits. And in its waiting, it reveals something profound:
The soul of the city does not live in monuments or megamalls, but in the intervals between footsteps,
in the pause of a street vendor,
and in the unnoticed rhythm of daily survival.
1. The Street as Stage
The scene unfolds like a living painting.
In the foreground, a man sits beside his meticulously arranged wares—socks and sandals, lined with precision.
His posture is folded, inward-looking. He holds a shallow metal tray, not as a plea but as a ritual.
His gaze does not seek the camera.
He is not performing.
He is simply there.
Behind him, life surges: women walk with purpose, a man in a beret strides by, another lingers mid-turn. No one stops. No one speaks to him.
And yet—it is his stillness that centers the composition.
“In every walk with nature, one receives far more than he seeks.”
— John Muir
Here, on this concrete sidewalk, the “nature” is human.
Not wild, not tamed, but improvised.
2. The Ethics of Seeing
As I look at this image, I recall Roland Barthes’ idea of the “punctum”—
the detail in a photo that pierces the viewer,
that makes it personal.
Here, the punctum is the quiet dignity of the vendor.
His presence speaks without sound.
In traditional Chinese thought, there is a term:
守拙 (shǒu zhuō) — to hold onto one's simple, humble self.
That is what I see in him. Not defeat, but modest continuity.
A life held upright by repetition.
“To see clearly is poetry, prophecy, and religion—all in one.”
— John Ruskin
What does it mean to see him without consuming him?
To photograph without turning a man into a metaphor?
This is the ethical dilemma of the lens:
It captures, but it must also care.
3. A Janus City: Modern and Ancient
To the far end of the street, glass towers rise,
traffic glints, and a mega billboard glows faintly under the afternoon haze.
KL is a city stretching in two directions:
towards a past that won’t disappear,
and a future that hasn’t quite arrived.
This street scene is a palimpsest—
modern ambition overlaid upon humble persistence.
“The street is a room by agreement.”
— Louis Kahn
But whose room is it?
The planner might draw its width.
The retailer might claim its footfall.
But the man with the tray—he inhabits it.
He imbues it with story.
4. The Everyday as Monument
Christopher Alexander reminds us in The Pattern Language that
the best public spaces are not those that dazzle but those that are used.
That support informal life. That grow organically from the ground up.
This photograph is an ode to that principle.
There is no grandeur here. No art installation.
No policy intervention.
Only the organic city, doing what cities were always meant to do:
host human variation.
This is the kind of urbanism that cannot be drawn on a masterplan—only lived.
5. Toward a Minor Urbanism
This photo is not just documentation.
It is resistance.
It resists the erasure of the minor.
It resists the speed of capital.
It resists the curated aesthetic of urban Instagram.
In its monochrome palette, it resembles the ash-gray brushworks of a literati scroll—
expressive, open-ended, grounded in observation.
It could be painted by a contemporary Cézanne or echoed by a weary Basquiat,
if he had walked these streets.
“The blue period was not a phase, it was a lens.”
— Attributed to Picasso
So too is this photograph.
A lens onto a world that most choose not to see.
6. The City as Chorus
Bukit Bintang is no stranger to spectacle.
But here, we find no spectacle—only chorus.
The passing feet.
The layered goods.
The suspended traffic.
The vendor's bowed head.
Together they form an urban cantata—
a composition not of melody, but of being-with.
“To be modern is to find ourselves in an environment that promises adventure, power, joy, growth… and, at the same time, threatens to destroy everything we have, everything we know.”
— Marshall Berman
This street, in all its contradictions, embodies that double-edge.
7. Closing: The Small Still Voice
In the noise of the city, this image listens.
It listens to the man who doesn’t speak.
To the goods that don’t sell.
To the people who pass without seeing.
And by capturing this quiet, the photo remembers.
It says:
This too is the city.
This too is part of the urban condition.
Not the skyline. Not the smart grid.
But the man with socks on a table and a bowl in his hands.
He is not beneath notice.
He is the notice.
No comments:
Post a Comment